A new “tier” with more teeth
This just in: Governor Cuomo’s 2012-13 Executive Budget has been posted online, and it does, indeed, include a 401(1)k-style defined-contribution (DC) retirement plan option.
Last year, the Governor proposed a “Tier 6″ pension plan that simply made adjustments to the existing defined-benefit (DB) pension system — raising retirement ages, extending the vesting period, boosting employee contributions, curbing use of overtime to pad pensions.
Today’s proposal is a big improvement.
On the DB side of the ledger, a key modification to the original proposal is a ” variable ‘risk/reward’ system under which employee contributions would decrease or increase, within limits, tied to economic conditions.” In addition, the new DB system would feature staggered schedule of employee contributions, ranging from 3 percent to 6 percent depending on salary level, with higher salaries paying more.
The “voluntary” 401(1)k-style plan would include a minimum employer contribution of 4 percent, which could increase to a maximum of 7 percent if the employee matches with a 3 percent contribution, bringing potential annual retirement savings to 11 10 percent. This, the Budget Message notes, would “offer a portability and (early) vesting feature not available with defined-benefit options.”
More details are to be found in Part H of this bill. Or, if you prefer, the bill memo.
Suffice to say, it’s a very big deal that Cuomo has put the DC concept on the table. The new “risk-reward” component of his DB reform is also noteworthy, because it gets at the heart of the problem — the one-sided assumption of financial risk by taxpayers.


Keep swinging the bat Andrew, singles are great however if you really want to hear the taxpayers cheer, point at the abuse in goverment and hit a home run. You are on the right track. Now is the time to swing right past Christi’s lead and finish the game in your ball park.
Comment by tony — January 17, 2012 @ 5:05 pm